The New York Times recently published a bombshell article revealing just how completely our every movement is tracked by companies in the business of selling our locations to advertisers, marketers and others. Anonymous sources provided the Times with a dataset from a single location-data company that contained 50 billion pings from the phones of more than 12 million Americans over several months in 2016 and 2017.
This data enabled the Times reporters to track numerous people in positions of power, including military officials, law-enforcement officers, and high-powered lawyers. They were able to watch as people visited the Playboy Mansion (some overnight) and they could see visitors to celebrity estates. Once they identified any particular phone they could track it wherever it went. Imagine what that data could be used for in the wrong hands.
No one intends to let unknown companies track their locations constantly. But code built into smartphone apps does just that often without our knowledge. Many of the apps that request access to location services have an entirely legitimate reason for doing so. For example, Google Maps can’t provide navigation directions unless it knows where you are. But others want location access for less practical reasons. Do you really want to let a coffeeshop app know your location at every moment in exchange for the occasional free latte? And some apps, notably weather apps, may have a legitimate need for location information but use that data for far more than users expect.
Even if you’re not too perturbed about companies you’ve never heard of knowing your exact whereabouts at all times (mostly to serve you more targeted advertising) there’s no guarantee this data couldn’t fall into the hands of foreign governments, organized crime or hackers willing to sell your movement patterns to an aggrieved employee, corporate spy, or jealous ex-lover.
Steps You Can Take to Protect Your Location Privacy
Luckily, Apple provides controls in iOS that let you limit your exposure. For most people going completely dark isn’t realistic. Too many iPhone capabilities require location services ranging from turn-by-turn directions, to geotagging photos, to using Find My to see if your kid has left the soccer tournament yet.
Nevertheless, going dark is a possibility: go to Settings > Privacy > Location Services and disable the Location Services switch at the top. That turns off location services for all apps, although iOS will turn them back on temporarily if you use Find My iPhone to enable Lost Mode.
Here’s what we recommend instead.
- Go to Settings > Privacy > Location Services and scroll down to see a list of every app on your iPhone that would like to know your location. (The same is true on the iPad, but fewer people use iPads as much while out and about.)
- For each app in the list, tap the app’s name to bring up the Allow Location Access screen which has up to four options:
- Never: Prevent this app from ever determining your location.
- Ask Next Time: The next time the app wants permission to track you, make it ask again.
- While Using the App: Allow the app to track your location as long as you’re actually using it.
- Always: Let the app track your location at all times, even when you’re not using it.
- Tap one of the options to select it, and then tap Back to return to the list.
We can’t tell you exactly how to configure each app since everyone has a different set and different levels of privacy worry. However, here is some advice:
- Apps and other entries from Apple are generally safe because Apple has an extremely strong privacy stance and excellent security against hacks. But down in System Services at the bottom, we’d turn off Location-Based Apple Ads and Popular Near Me even if Apple is collecting this data anonymously, it’s still being used to sell things to you, not to provide useful services to you.
- For most apps, change the Allow Location Access setting to Ask Next Time to force each app to prompt you again. If it asks at a point where it’s reasonable that it would need to know your location, such as Yelp wanting to show you nearby restaurants, grant it. If you don’t understand why it’s asking or if the request seems weak (“To show you which wines are available for purchase in your area.”), deny the request.
- With apps that obviously need location services, such a parking app that needs to know which area you’re in change the setting to While Using App and see if that meets your needs.
- Only if you clearly need to allow a particular app to track your location in the background (turn-by-turn navigation apps are the most common) should you change that setting to Always. Almost no apps should be given such power and many won’t even provide the option.
There’s one unusual item in the list: Safari Websites. It’s a master switch that lets Web sites loaded in Safari ask for your location. That’s probably not a major privacy concern but few Web sites provide sufficiently useful location-based features (mostly for finding nearby chain store outlets) that it’s worth bothering.
In the end, go with your gut. If thinking about a particular app or company potentially recording your location constantly gives you the creeps, turn it off and either find an alternative or do without. Legislation may be the only solution in the end but for now we can take steps like these to protect ourselves.
(Featured image based on an original by Garik Barseghyan from Pixabay)
The biggest challenge in this digital always connected age is that there is SO MUCH to manage.... configurations, personal settings, privacy, backups, authentication, password management, syncing of info (contacts, reminders, calendars,...) etc, etc etc...
Multiply that by the number of devices, and PC software and phone apps for each, one needs to maintain in a household, and you start to almost need full time IT support, FOR PERSONAL USE!
I have yet to find an adequate solution to reduce the burden.
Hi, Solomon. We agree with you 100% — managing all of this is becoming increasingly more challenging.
P.S. I have argued that I see this seriously contributing to the decline of mental health in our society... this is not just increasingly more challenging, it is at the point of having serious negative impact on people's health... The camel's back is going to break...
Anyone have a reasonable solution, short of living disconnected and off the grid? :-(
That's an important point, fc.smayer97. I think we're all grieving, either consciously or unconsciously, our expectations for privacy and the fact that we'll always be vulnerable to unplanned events from pandemics to cybercrime and even other human errors that put ourselves and others at risk.
There's no perfect solution but there is a chance to elevate our average consumer awareness that we do leak information all over the place from every Internet-connected device we add to our lives. When we walk into a big box store with bluetooth on, when we sign up for loyalty programs, when we introduce a new piece of technology into our lives, the companies who design these products/offerings collect info on us and they don't care about our security or our privacy.
So the work falls on us as consumers to do the work of staying informed, just enough to do our own due diligence. Some of us view this as additional burden. Others view it as an empowering exercise in being aware of our surroundings as they continue to change and challenge our far outdated perspectives on privacy and security. It's not a conversation everyone is always excited to have but it's an important one! Thanks for offering your thoughts. No small thing.
Please sign in to leave a comment.